Friday, September 01, 2006

The Annotated Bibliography

Topic - Principles of design relating to websites and print media.


Website posture and manner

Http://www.merges.net/theory/20010215.html


This website outlines the importance of flow that greatly affects a user’s experience while surfing a particular website. In paraphrasing software designer Alan Cooper, Adam Baker describes flow as an experience that is not frustrating and allows users to concentrate entirely on what they are looking for. He defines flow into two key elements, namely posture and manner. Posture according to Cooper is the stance (in rhetoric studies terms) portrayed by the website or in simpler terms, how the website presents itself to the user. Baker describes manner as the “mood” of a website. He also describes manner as how the website communicates with the user, be it the language of the website or the design of error pages.

I found this website particularly useful. It is a short write up but is full of impact. Examples were given to show illustrations of bad web page design. For newbies like me, I would really want to know what NOT to do. Cooper explains how a web page design should be from the user’s point of view. He understands that most web users are not computer experts and should not be fed with technical waffle if an error page occurs. This was a very important statement to me. I would think of consumer first before applying my own desired design. Cooper also explains that users aren’t just users anymore, they are consumers who can be loyal customers. To me a website is just like an extension of a boutique in a shopping mall. The same kind of service should be replicated if possible to provide a pleasant experience for the consumer.





A Dao of Web Design

http://alistapart.com/articles/dao


This article by John Allsopp uses the Tao Te Ching teachings as a backdrop to illustrate his understanding of web design. He finds that people often apply old print ideas onto web design, which will not work that effectively in the end. The Tao draws heavily from human experience and is strongly associated with harmony. Each section starts off with a small excerpt from the Tao teachings and may not make sense at first, but Allsopp slowly pieces together both his thoughts and the Tao teachings to explain how web design should be like.

In short, this article explains the inflexibility of men of not adapting to changes. To Allsopp, people would still apply layout concepts found on the older print form onto the new world of web design. They would want control over everything and as such they forsake the accessibility of the website. As such Allsopp feels that web designers should learn to adapt and not make elaborate designs which only complicate matters further.
This article also explains what should or should not be done, ranging from fonts to colours and layout.

One thing I’ve learnt, let the web be the web. After having searched through a few articles, they all come back with the same thing, print designs will not work on the web! Another thing is learning to adapt and not stick to old concepts is a virtue. The main idea is probably to embrace the new world of the web gracefully. One thing I’ve learnt is rather deep Tao philosophy too, and I’ll probably try to dumbfound my friends with my new knowledge!






Web Sites that Work

http://www.fastcompany.com/online/10/rogerblack.html


This is an article by Hiawatha Bay. But in fact for the most part, Bay lists the six rules that Roger Black abides by to create his famous designs. Black’s designs have appeared in “Rolling Stones”, “Newsweek” and many others. Strangely, having read that print layout concepts usually will not work for web designs, it was interesting to know that his six rules apply to web design! His designs have appeared on websites like USA Today, The Discovery Channel and The National Park Service.

The Six Rules:

1. Big is better! Basically it makes things look better and of course easier to read, especially on your computer screen.


2. Use colour sparingly. Black recommends not mixing too much colour to the webpage. He prefers red, black and white. These colours are easy to the eye grab the most attention. He emphasizes the importance of contrast between the texts and the background.


3. Ensure that the page loads fast. Intense graphics are a no no. Place all artwork in a separate gallery to allow users to download them separately.


4. Content is the most important. Place important information at places that are easily accessible and noticeable. Users tend to skim through websites like what they do in print thus information placement is vital.


5. Keep scrolling minimal. It helps in achieving the smooth flow of the website.


6. Keep content straight to the point. Most sites share nothing worthwhile with their users and will get them irritated and not find what they want. Point is to provide them an engaging experience.

Basic principles of Layout


http://www.signweb.com/index.php/channel/10/id/333/


An online resource from the "Signs of the Times" magazine, this article provides a crash course on the basic principles of layout which include balance, rhythm, unity and harmony. Many factors influence the outcome of a layout – amount of copy, letter styles, illustrations and the job price. These factors are then further influenced by questions of whether the sign is made to inform or to sell, to sell an item or service? Physical factors include whether the sign is viewed up close or far away, or is the sign facing fast or slow traffic? These are some of the questions that would be frequently going through my mind in the making of my brochure and should also be considered religiously by people who are attempting to come up with the perfect design.
Balance, rhythm, unity and harmony are the different principles in layout where no one principle is more important than the other. Each of these principles must coordinate with one another to create a well made sign.


Balance – Balance is about correct weight distribution of the different objects of a design. It should not mean that it should be done symmetrically but that it should be pleasing to the eye. Letter spacing, word spacing and copy division should all be carefully considered to give that stable feel to the design.


Rhythm – Rhythm here talks mainly about the correct use of fonts. Never use more than two styles of fonts on one sign! A sign usually has a patterned recurrence of lines, forms and colours which make it aesthetically pleasing. Too much styles of font prove to be visually stressing to the eye.


Unity – Unity is defined as to place unequal or seemingly unrelated entities found in a design into one single cohesive form. The eye should travel uninterrupted when browsing through the different messages found in a design. Contrasting lines can be used to separate the different messages.


Harmony - Harmony is achieved by combining balance, rhythm and unity into creating a successful layout.


This article also dwells into more technical aspects of creating a good a layout. It talks about how simply a border can destroy a good layout that already has other good elements. It also discusses about how a formal layout, though dull and unattractive but its square and angularity are sometimes required in some to show its seriousness. Another would be radiance. It is how the design pulls the viewer’s interest. Curvature in design is an important feature too. A simple arched line of an object on a design can bring out an otherwise dull layout that is square.
I felt this can be applied to both print and web designs, thus my decision to annotate this particular article. This article has a good mix of both technical aspects and answers to many questions.




Top Ten Web Design Mistakes of 2002


Http://www.useit.com/alertbox/20021223.html


This article is written by Jakob Nielson. A very short and straight to the point article, with quirky comic strips make this a very fun read. He has written other articles relating to web design and they can be found in his column, Alertbox, in Useit.com Most notable are the articles in which he lists out common mistakes found in web designs and dates back all the way till ten years ago in 1996. He points out that the old mistakes still occur in today's websites although they get less common. He also mentions that as the older problems get solved, new problems will occur. Such recurrences of problems only serve to deteoriate customer experience and will cost owners business.


Nielson's article lists the top ten design mistakes that (in what he terms as) "punishes" users.
1. No prices
Many web sites have made the mistake of leaving out the price when what the consumers really want to know is how much they will have to spend. For my brochure, the price will definitely be stated there for the price is one of the factors that attracts them.


2. Inflexible search engines
Search engines can be difficult for the elderly users when they may have problems spelling out the query term properly. Search engines also have the tendency to be sensitive to typo errors, plurals, hyphens and other various mistakes.


3. Horizontal scrolling
As with some of the articles I've annotated, excess scrolling puts off users. Nielson mentions scrolling left to right in particular, where most users would be relatively be okay with vertical scrolling but annoyed when scrolling horizontally.


4. Fixed font size
Nielson observed that web sites usually have fixed font sizes, thus not allowing font sizes to be changed. This poses a problem for the elderly when most fonts on these websites are really tiny. Sites then in 2002 probably have problems with font size. With my current experiences in websites, most websites allow the font size change mode, for example, small, medium and large.


5. Blocks of text
What this really means is too much text which can be really boring. Nielson recommends the use of subheads, bulleted lists, highlighted keywords, short paragraphs, the inverted pyramid, a simple writng style and language devoid of marketese.


6. JavaScript in links
Links should behave simply by replacing the current page with the new content. Opening the new content in another window may annoy users greatly as it a great disruption to the flow.


7. Infrequently asked questions in FAQ
Some websites offer solutions to questions that seem unneccessary. By putting up such questions reduces the site's credibility.


8. Collecting email addresses without a privacy policy
Users are getting very protective of their inboxes. When the site requests for the email address, a privacy statement should be provided. People should also be asked if they want newsltters coming to their email and also be informed of its frequency.


9. URL > 75 characters
This simply means the web address should not be exuberantly long. URLs should be user friendly as well where the user will conveniently remember it and thus refer back to the site.


10. Mailto links in unexpected locations
Mailto links shoud appear exclusively on email addresses, i.e rick@price.com. They should not appear on people's names when people would most likely expect to see a biography of the person rather than seeing the mailto screen.




Differences bewtween print design and web design

Http://www.useit.com/alertbox/990124.html

Another article by Jakob Nielson, this time comparing the differences between print and web design. For many designers, they would involve the already well developed print designs onto web designs. But as Nielson mentions in one part of the article, "Anything that is a great print design is likely to be a lousy web design.", and it seems that the designers have got it all wrong. This particular statement has been observed in other sites as well and I for one, have started to slowly piece together the differences in both these mediums and slowly understand the meaning to this important statement.


Nielson explains the differences of the two mediums in terms of dimensionality, navigation, response time, resolution and canvas size, and finally multimedia interactivity. He feels the while print design is letting the eyes browse through the infomation and letting the high impact visual elements on the print explain itself, the web functions by letting the user use his hands to move the information and has the power to allow for interaction with the user.


Of course, such functions come at a price and certain things have to be sacrificed. Newspapers have a large canvas to play on. High resolution graphics and colourful details are common in print. The web allows that but applying the same print layout on the web only increases scrolling around and increased loading time. Reading the small fonts off a newsapaper is easy but definitely not feasible when reading off the computer screen.


Nielson mentions however that such things may change in due time as technology gets better. Bandwidth gets faster and may allow pages to load as fast as you turn a page in the newspaper or the screen resolution may be get sharp and crisp enough to allow reading off the screen a breeze.

The Principles of Design


http://www.digital-web.com/articles/principles_of_design


A very theoratical write up by Joshua David McClurg about the principles of design. This is one of the three articles written by McClurg who is writing a column in this webpage about web design. It dwells into the basics of design which can be applied in various mediums although the website itself involves discussions more for web design. McClurg mentions that design is one of the disciplines within the scope of art and within art itself lies a few fundamental principles which art lives by. As such design will also involve these fundamental principles.


McClurg discusses the following principles in detail, namely balance, rhythm, proportion, dominance, unity and other related concepts. The mentioned principles have been found in other resources that I've found, like balance, rhythm and unity.As I read through the article, I kept thinking in terms of what would be best for my upcoming brochure.


I learnt alot about symmetry, like how different sizes of the same shape give more visual tension and how different objects lend weight in a design.


Rhythm creates that sense of flow and movement. It can create a movement that is lively or evoke other feelings depending on how it is created. For the upcoming brochure, I can see myself using "rhythm" alot, probably to create that fleeting feel, a sense of get away to accentuate the feel free atmosphere of Tibet.

Proportion is the distribution of forms or shapes. The different sizes lead to different interpretations of the composition.

Dominance refers to the varying emphasis of the objects found in the composition. The placement of the different objects give the composition depth and space. Interestingly, a drawn picture of a few trees in the foreground and houses in the background in a mountainous area was the example for this particular section...reminds me of Tibet.

Unity
This describes the fusion of the different concepts and principles to make the whole composition make sense.

Take the 5 Minute Brochure Design Trash Test


http://sbinformation.about.com/od/advertisingpr/

a/brochuredesign.htm


A very important article to me, this piece by Darrell Zahorsky creates a five minute brochure design test to see if the brochure created is destined for the trash can. The test is split into diffrent timelines and each timeline indicates what questions to be asked. The questions are, appeal to emotions, be professional, be personal, achieve readability, speak the language, lead with beneftis, have a single message, focus on a product or service, make an action call and finally add your score.

For the upcoming brochure about travelling in Tibet, I'll definitely be utilising this trash test, for I've been guilty of throwing away tonnes of brochures myself! Now that I'm engaged in designing a brochure, I would not want my brochures to be thrown away at first sight! As Zahorsky says we only have that one chance to make an impact and to do that we have got to have a sound brochure design and good brochure writing principles.

That would involve appealing to the masses by relating to their wants or pains (Appeal to emotion).

The quality of the brochure plays an important part too, and that would involve using quality paper, applying high quality graphics or images (Being professional).

The brochure must connect with the customer personally (Be personal), and entice the customer through his own experiences and not through selfish selling of their own product.

A brochure has to be easy to the eye (Achieve readability), where the eye rolls over the information at ease and absorbs the neccessary information easily.

Technical terms and jargon will be omitted (Speak the language). The language should be simple and is easy for the customer digest.

Sell the product according to its benefits and not by its feature (Lead with benefits).

Make the brochure as simple as possible with just one single impactful message (Have a single message). Too much information fed to the customers only confuses them.

Focus on a single product or service rather catalouging the whole range if products.

Directing the customer to a making a phone call or placing the website address to look for further is a must. (Make an action call)




Other useful websites regarding principles of design

http://www.ncsu.edu/viste/dtp/index.html
http://www.rensch.com/brochure-checklist.htm

The Buzz (An Introduction to Myself)

Hi again! I’m so sorry I was bickering non stop in my first two entries without even introducing myself! Thoughts come fast and furious, there are so many things to write about, so I couldn’t help but pen it all down first before the thoughts disappear forever (reminder once again to all the Einsteins, THE BRAIN RECORDER!)


Ok, before I digress again, I am Xiong Zhihao! Hello! =)


Nickname, Buzz or Buzzer. Chinese nickname, XiongXiong, which means Bearbear in English. Strangely, my family name means bear in Chinese. Oh well, it’s the perfect excuse for people to hug their lovely bear hehe..


I am a 23 year old male, the only child in my family. But my family knows that is old news now, for I have a little dog, Lucky, whom entered the family almost 7 years ago and she definitely gets all the attention now **POUTS** I love her still, in fact I love her soooo much!

Picture of me and Lucky, my darling sister! Being an only child can get lonely sometimes, thus my parents saw the need to buy a dog to brighten up our lives. I'm glad it did!

Lucky. To me, she's really human. Look at how she smiles!

I love taking pictures from this particular window which faces west. Every sunshine would be almost perfect.

Me and my polytechnic friends. Probably spent the best times of my life there. Getting to meet different people from all over Singapore in such a big campus. We're still remain very good firends till this day.

In the army. Very tough. Very tiring. Very depressing.

Sounds like it was bad thing? I'm actually grateful I got the opportunity to serve my country. It has made me grow up alot more I believe. Some things in life do not seem so tough anymore. I'll probably enter some entries regarding my time served in the army. Hope to enlighten the helpless soul out there!

The National Day Parade. I was an assistant dance instructor for the Parade's mass display item for two years. I had to teach young students ranging from 13 to 16 years old to learn to how to dance!

This blog is set up to –
1. Comment critically in the form of an annotated bibliography on 7 different articles regarding design and publication. This is one of the assignments for the Document Design and Publication module of the University of South Australia. I hope that the stranger out there who reads this will find the critiques useful.


2. No blog will be complete without of course introducing yourself! Pictures and short write ups will all be part of the deal.


3. One thing that I’ve observed is that blogs can be rather depressing? They usually talk about their worries or their unhappiness, never once talking about the their happier moments in life.

4. Is life really that miserable? As such, I promise to all readers, this blog will never have an entry that emanates that aura of death and uncertainty. I will make my entries happy. I’ll find meaning even in moments of sadness and try my best to reach out to everybody. I hope you’ll find certain entries enlightening and more importantly, they’ll put a smile on your face.

5. Relate the articles to the upcoming project I'm working on. The project involves making a travel brochure, destination Tibet. I would be thinking in terms of communicating effectively and creating that punchy brochure that is sure to grab the attention of the unsuspecting passerby.

6. Swearing… this seems like a normal part in most blogs. Can’t say much for now for I’m still treating this as an academic blog! Just don’t piss me off and maybe this blog will be vulgarities free haha!

Thursday, August 31, 2006

The Purpose (Foreword)

HELLO! Greetings to the people of this vast and never ending world of the Internet. A huge thank you for taking time to read my blog. How exciting, this being the first entry that’s going into my very first blog!

Honestly, I never had the habit of putting pen to paper, you can almost say I never liked writing. I cannot express myself well while writing down whatever I’m thinking. It gets tiring after a while. My train of thought gets disrupted easily when I am concentrating on writing out the words, when in fact I should be concentrating on what to write and how well to write instead.

My thoughts come about easily when I’m talking to myself, in my head. It simply flows. Sometimes you would have wished there is technology to easily record whatever you were thinking in your head, either that or you would have just wished you had super human memory! It is always a pain to come up with that one moment of genius but only to forget about it later due to insufficient brain food.

New technologies have made things a lot easier. Now I do not need to have an aching hand just to write down all my thoughts, thank heavens for computers although the brain recorder idea would be the best!

All in all, whether its writing it down or typing it out, they all still serve the same purpose, and talking about purpose, what is the purpose of starting this blog? Well, a blog to me works like a diary, where you pen down what you have been doing, your thoughts about life and all that. It works this way for most people’s blogs. Some blogs dwell into politics, usually questioning or praising their government. Some critically commenting the latest movies or…(train of thought just crashed, Einsteins of the world, come up with the brain recorder thing now!!!)